Aaron Rodgers and Patrick Mahomes headline The Athletic's most up-to-date quarterback tiers record, adopted by Tom Brady, Josh Allen, and Justin Herbert.
Rodgers acquired a mean vote of 1.00, solidifying him within the high spot, whereas Mahomes got here in second at 1.02, which means one voter was the deciding issue between him and Rodgers.
That is the place the controversy begins. Ought to Rodgers be above Mahomes on the record?
Patrick Mahomes criticized for taking part in 'road ball' by an NFL DC
Kansas Metropolis Chiefs QB Patrick Mahomes ranked second in The Athletic’s quarterback tiers proper behind Inexperienced Bay Packers’ Aaron Rodgers. Shannon Sharpe reacts to the rating.
Shannon Sharpe delivered his take, primarily based on that single voter citing his opinion that Mahomes has misplaced video games by counting on his "pure pocket presence."
"I've an enormous downside with it," Sharpe says. "How a lot road ball did he play in the perfect sport that occurred final 12 months, Buffalo-Kansas Metropolis? What number of quarterbacks do you imagine within the historical past of the sport might have executed what Mahomes did? Within the last two minutes of the sport, what number of quarterbacks might have executed that?
"The 12 months they gained the Tremendous Bowl, they fell behind 24. The opposite sport, they fell behind 10 factors. How a lot was road ball?"
Sharpe argued that within the final seven or eight video games of the 2021 season when groups had been forcing Mahomes to go to his second or third possibility, he nonetheless threw for 314 yards per sport, 23 touchdowns, 4 interceptions and a 71% completion fee.
"They're getting outrageous with this now," Sharpe mentioned. "To say now, you are going to take these spotlight performs and use that towards him. The performs that he runs out of the pocket and he might throw the ball 55 yards, they're utilizing that towards him."
Since changing into a starter in his second season in 2018, Mahomes has accomplished 66.1% of his passes for 301.4 yards per sport, 37.8 touchdowns per season (2.4 touchdowns per sport) and in these 4 years, has thrown 36 whole interceptions, equaling 9 per season. His file in these 4 seasons is 49-13, and he led the Chiefs to a Tremendous Bowl win in 2020.
Since 2018, Rodgers has accomplished 65.9% of his passes for 263 yards per sport, 34 touchdowns per season (2.1 per sport), and threw 15 interceptions over these 4 years, 3.8 per season. His file over the earlier 4 seasons is 45-18-1, and the Inexperienced Bay Packers misplaced within the convention championship twice and the divisional spherical this previous season.
"Though Aaron Rodgers has 4 MVPs, what number of Tremendous Bowls has he been to within the final 4 years?" Sharpe added. "Mahomes has been equally as spectacular."
